Article
6 minutes read

When Information Stops Being Power

What the arrival of AI changes about the source of a leader's authority, and the skills that matter more because of it.

In this article

Share this article

Kingsley Gate’s video conversation series, Untamed, brings senior leaders together for candid conversations about the moments that tested them and the forces reshaping how they lead. In the first episode, host Christine Sobhani, a Senior Partner at Kingsley Gate who has spent 25 years in executive search, was joined by Bregje “Bee” Meuwissen, Chief People Officer at Cint, a global market research technology company with around 800 employees across 18 countries. A large part of their conversation examined what artificial intelligence is doing to leadership itself.

One of Bee’s observations reframes a question many executives are quietly asking. For most of the modern history of management, authority rested in large part on information. The person at the top of the organization was often the person who knew the most, who had seen more cycles, sat in more rooms, and held context the rest of the team did not have. Bee’s argument is that this particular advantage has largely dissolved.

“When you were a leader in an organization, you had authority through the fact that you had more information, more experience, that you knew things others didn’t. With AI coming in, that benefit has gone, because everybody has all the knowledge and all the information.”

— Bregje “Bee” Meuwissen, Chief People Officer, Cint

Why holding more information no longer sets leaders apart

When a first-year analyst can put a question to a model that a twenty-year veteran might once have answered, and receive a competent response in seconds, the gap that used to separate them tends to narrow. This is less a story of machines replacing experts than of expertise becoming widely available. Anthropic’s Economic Index, which studies how people actually use these tools, found that most use leans toward augmentation over automation, roughly 57 percent against 43 percent, which suggests people generally reach for AI to raise the level of their own work rather than to hand it over. What erodes in that shift is the exclusivity of knowledge. The value of the judgment applied to it usually remains.

If knowing more than the room is no longer the differentiator, something has to take its place. Bee locates it in the questions a leader is able to ask.

“It’s gone from I have all the answers to I need to know which questions to ask. And I need to be transparent and vulnerable enough with my teams to say I don’t know all the answers. I’m trying to figure out what the questions are that need to be asked.”

— Bregje “Bee” Meuwissen, Chief People Officer, Cint

The move from having the answers to asking the right questions

This is a meaningful change in the skill set, and a growing body of commentary now frames question-asking as one of the more durable leadership capabilities in an AI era. When answers are inexpensive and instant, much of the value shifts to how well a problem is framed, which is to say to the quality of the questions being asked. The willingness to say “I don’t know yet” matters as well. In a setting where almost any claim can be checked in seconds, a leader who signals certainty they do not have is often exposed more quickly than they once were.

There is a risk hidden in this. If questions become the advantage, the easy response is to let the tool generate the questions too. Bee’s own practice runs in the other direction. She describes a technique she calls reverse prompting.

“Instead of letting the AI tell you what it is, you ask the AI to question you first. It helps you think more critically rather than giving you answers.”

— Bregje “Bee” Meuwissen, Chief People Officer, Cint

How leaning on AI can quietly weaken judgment

That habit, using the model to interrogate one’s reasoning rather than to supply a conclusion, matters because the alternative carries a measurable cost. In a 2025 study presented at the CHI conference, researchers at Microsoft and Carnegie Mellon surveyed 319 knowledge workers about 936 real uses of generative AI. They found that the more a worker trusted the tool’s output, the less critical thinking that worker tended to apply. The authors caution that handing routine work to the machine can remove the everyday practice that keeps judgment sharp, leaving it, in their words, “atrophied and unprepared” when a difficult case arrives. The same tool can strengthen judgment or weaken it, depending largely on whether it is used to answer the user or to question them.

Bee connects this to bias, where the stakes become concrete. These systems learned from the past.

“It’s completely real and totally underestimated. It’s not a rogue AI. We trained it on historical data, and historical data is biased.”

— Bregje “Bee” Meuwissen, Chief People Officer, Cint

Her point is that whatever a model recognizes as good is assembled from what an organization already believed. Left to operate on its own, it tends to return the established view faster and with more apparent authority, rather than introducing new thinking. That is much of the reason a person needs to stay in the decision. The role is to ask the question the data cannot ask of itself, which is whether the pattern it has found is one worth keeping.

Why information overload makes prioritization a core leadership skill

A quieter shift runs alongside the first. When anyone can generate a nine-page memo in a minute, the volume of material a leader has to absorb rises sharply. Bee gave a simple illustration. Producing a long document used to take real effort, so people tended to write a page or less. Now the nine pages are almost free, and teams can find themselves buried in them. The capability that becomes valuable is the ability to step back, prioritize, and draw out what matters, and then to commit to a direction without holding every fact.

“You have to be able to look really conceptually at things versus having all the data at your fingertips. Nobody knows where this is going. So we need to make decisions on a direction without actually having all the facts, which takes courage and resilience.”

— Bregje “Bee” Meuwissen, Chief People Officer, Cint

What this changes about how organizations identify leaders

For anyone responsible for assessing leaders, this reshapes what is worth looking for. Several of the signals that once stood in for capability, such as years served, information accumulated, and the confident answer delivered in the room, are among the things AI has made widely available. What it does not replicate is judgment under uncertainty, the quality of a person’s questions, and the composure to say “I don’t know yet” as the beginning of a sound process rather than the end of one. These qualities are harder to measure than a line on a resume, and they are arguably more predictive of senior performance than they have been in some time. It is a shift that sits close to the center of how Kingsley Gate approaches the assessment of leaders, weighing a person’s judgment rather than their command of information a machine now shares with everyone. As information becomes abundant, the ability to ask good questions of it is becoming a larger part of what sets strong leaders apart.

Sources

  1. International Labour Organization and NASK, “Generative AI and jobs: A 2025 update,” May 2025.

  2. Anthropic Economic Index, on augmentation versus automation in AI use, 2025.

  3. Lee et al., “The Impact of Generative AI on Critical Thinking,” Microsoft and Carnegie Mellon University, CHI 2025.

  4. MIT Sloan Executive Education, on question-asking as a leadership skill in the AI era.

Search for your next leader

Our first conversation will be a collaborative exercise where our consultants will go through a discovery process that will deliver a search strategy validated by you in real time.​​

Download our Full Report on

Headline

Kingsley Gate Partners, LLC needs the contact information you provide to us to contact you about our products and services. You may unsubscribe from these communications at any time. For information on how to unsubscribe, as well as our privacy practices and commitment to protecting your privacy, please review our Privacy Policy.