Article
6 minutes read

AI is absorbing the early-career work where judgment is built

Consequences will surface years later in the leadership pipeline.

In this article

Share this article

Kingsley Gate’s video conversation series, Untamed, brings senior leaders together for candid conversations about the moments that tested them and the forces reshaping how they lead. In the first episode, host Christine Sobhani, a Senior Partner at Kingsley Gate who has spent 25 years in executive search, was joined by Bregje “Bee” Meuwissen, Chief People Officer at Cint, a global market research technology company with around 800 employees across 18 countries. Part of their conversation turned to a question that receives less attention than it deserves, which is what AI is doing to the people entering and moving through organizations.

When the discussion reached what worried Christine most about AI, she did not point to the most senior roles. She pointed to the start of the career, and to her own children.

“I don’t believe AI is going to take the place of senior leadership, because there still needs to be human connection, empathy, hard conversations. My worry comes much more to my kids. When they graduate, they’ll have a harder time than we did, because the junior level is what AI is replacing.”

— Christine Sobhani, host of Untamed and Senior Partner, Kingsley Gate

Where the disruption is actually landing

That concern is increasingly supported by evidence. In “Canaries in the Coal Mine,” a 2026 study from the Stanford Digital Economy Lab, Erik Brynjolfsson and colleagues found that employment of workers aged 22 to 25 in the most AI-exposed occupations now sits roughly 19 percent below where it would have been had it kept pace with their less-exposed peers. The adjustment has come mainly through reduced hiring rather than layoffs, and employment for more experienced workers in the same fields has generally held steady or risen. The disruption, in other words, is concentrated at the entrance to the workforce.

Why entry-level work is where judgment gets built

That entrance does more than provide a first salary. In Bee’s view, it is also where people build the capabilities that later make them worth promoting.

“You start a job, you’re learning, you’re failing, and you get some scar tissue around what worked and what didn’t. That builds your judgment and your experience. That whole layer is being challenged by AI.”

— Bregje “Bee” Meuwissen, Chief People Officer, Cint

This is the quieter problem beneath the headline about jobs. The tasks AI takes on first, the first draft, the first model, the first analysis, are often the same tasks that used to turn a junior employee into someone with judgment. When those tasks are automated, people can still be promoted on schedule, but they may reach larger roles without the experience that used to come with the climb. Bee describes the gap between how quickly the tools move and how slowly capability tends to develop.

“When the technology makes things quicker, the capabilities don’t necessarily catch up at the same time. The AI can do all these things, so the people can now resolve bigger issues, but they haven’t been trained for that.”

— Bregje “Bee” Meuwissen, Chief People Officer, Cint

A simple example shows the mechanism. A junior analyst who once built a model by hand, breaking it, correcting it, and learning why a figure moved, may now prompt a tool that returns a finished version in seconds. The output is often better and faster. The learning that used to be attached to the work is what tends to go missing. Repeated across a team and several years, the result can be a group of managers who operate the tools well but understand the underlying problems less deeply than their predecessors did.

Why the disruption falls harder on women

The effect is not spread evenly. The International Labour Organization’s May 2025 study found that around one in four jobs worldwide is exposed to generative AI, and that the exposure skews toward women. In high-income countries, the roles at highest risk account for 9.6 percent of women’s employment, close to three times the share for men, largely because women are overrepresented in the clerical, administrative, and financial-support roles that generative AI tends to automate first. In the conversation, Bee referred to an Anthropic report making a related observation. The public Anthropic Economic Index shows AI use concentrated in mid-to-high-wage professional work rather than at the extremes of the pay scale. Read together, the two findings place the middle of the professional pipeline, which skews female, within the part of the workforce being reshaped.

This matters for leadership because those mid-level professional roles are the pool from which senior leaders are eventually drawn. If that layer thins, and thins fastest for women, the leadership pipeline narrows years before any executive search begins. The first step up is already the weakest point for women. According to the 2024 Women in the Workplace report from McKinsey and LeanIn, for every 100 men promoted from entry level to manager, only 81 women are promoted. AI has the potential to widen that gap rather than close it.

Why coaching is becoming more important than mentorship

If AI has made knowledge widely available, the way experience is passed down has to change with it. Bee draws a useful distinction between two things that are often blurred.

“Mentorship was I’ve been there, I’ve done that, so I can help you. Coaching is where are you, and how can I help you work through this. A lot of the knowledge is available now through AI. What’s not available is the judgment that comes with experience.”

— Bregje “Bee” Meuwissen, Chief People Officer, Cint

As people move into larger roles faster, and carry heavier responsibility earlier, the greater need is less for someone to transfer information, which the tools already do, and more for someone to help them develop judgment they did not have time to accumulate gradually. Organizations that anticipate this are beginning to treat coaching as core infrastructure rather than a benefit reserved for a select few, and to build it in early rather than waiting until a capable but under-seasoned manager stalls in a role they reached quickly.

The link between cognitive offloading and inherited bias

The part of Bee’s argument that unsettles her most is a loop. If younger professionals rely on AI to do their thinking, they may not develop the capacity to question it later, and the tool they are relying on carries the biases of the past.

“If young people don’t learn to think for themselves, they can never do higher-level critical thinking, because they haven’t learned to think in the first place. They offload the thinking to their AIs. And that comes back to the biases built into the AI. So we go into this circle that is quite scary.”

— Bregje “Bee” Meuwissen, Chief People Officer, Cint

The research lends support to the mechanism. The same Microsoft and Carnegie Mellon study of knowledge workers found that greater trust in an AI’s output was associated with less critical thinking, and warned that offloading routine work can leave judgment unprepared for the exceptions. Universities and schools are raising comparable concerns about students. A generation that has not had to reason through the straightforward cases may be less prepared for the difficult ones, and the difficult cases tend to define senior roles.

How organizations can protect the experience pipeline

None of this argues against the tools. It argues for protecting the development that the tools can quietly erode. In practice, that tends to involve three things. The first is designing junior roles so that people still practice judgment rather than only supervising a model. The second is investing in coaching as the early rungs thin, since the experience that once came at no cost now has to be built deliberately. The third is monitoring the pipeline by gender, rather than assuming that fairness at the point of hiring corrects a problem that is forming upstream. For any organization that will need senior leaders a decade from now, the experience gap is already forming in the present, and the organizations that recognize it early are the ones most likely to still have a strong field of leaders to choose from.

Sources

  1. Brynjolfsson, Chandar and Chen, “Canaries in the Coal Mine? Six Facts about the Recent Employment Effects of Artificial Intelligence,” Stanford Digital Economy Lab, 2026.

  2. International Labour Organization and NASK, “Generative AI and jobs: A 2025 update,” May 2025.
  3. Anthropic Economic Index, 2025.

  4. Lee et al., “The Impact of Generative AI on Critical Thinking,” Microsoft and Carnegie Mellon University, CHI 2025.

  5. McKinsey and LeanIn.org, “Women in the Workplace 2024.

Search for your next leader

Our first conversation will be a collaborative exercise where our consultants will go through a discovery process that will deliver a search strategy validated by you in real time.​​

Download our Full Report on

Headline

Kingsley Gate Partners, LLC needs the contact information you provide to us to contact you about our products and services. You may unsubscribe from these communications at any time. For information on how to unsubscribe, as well as our privacy practices and commitment to protecting your privacy, please review our Privacy Policy.